Phone - (717)763-7631
Fax - (717)763-4958
Toll Free - (800)338-9392

24 Hour Contact Form

Read what our clients say!


"I have been a customer with Consumer Insurance Agency for 25+ years. They have always been professional and courteous and have handled the few claims I have had expeditiously and appropriately. Their new newsletter and website are both welcome additives to their quest to be the best. "

Henry Panckeri – Mechanicsburg, PA

 

"I contacted Diane Jacobs a few times this summer after she initially called to update our personal information. She was always pleasant, professional and knowledgeable. I appreciate her ability to explain in layman’s terms various options."

Alice and Ed Knutsen – Hershey, PA

 

"May I say that I am tickled pink, with the service of your agency? Erie Insurance cut my auto premium in half! Same coverage- half price- how wonderful!"

Matthew Slifko – Etters, PA

 

“Insuring my commercial real estate through Consumers Insurance Agency makes all the sense in the world.  Eric and his team convincingly demonstrated their expertise by helping me discover what I needed, and then matched me with the program that made the most sense for my situation.  Even though I’m in York and they’re in Camp Hill, I find it very easy to do business with them.”

W. Alan Snook II – PDL Enterprises, LLC, York, PA

 

“We have been customers with Consumers Insurance Agency for years and have always been satisfied with the service we have received. They are always courteous and take the time to answer any questions we have or provide any information we need.”

Carl and Barbara Heisey – Dalmatia, PA

 

“The team at Consumers Insurance Agency has always been helpful with my needs which is why we’ve been customers for over 20 years.”

Hank Seidel – Camp Hill, PA

 

“Our agent, Ann Byrne, showed us how we can get the same coverage and in some cases better coverage for less money on our auto insurance and also our homeowners.”

John and Connie Stoner – Mechanicsburg, PA

 

“First of all and most important to me was the immediate response and attention that I received from Ann.  I also got other quotes from four (4) other agencies.  I not only got a better quote but much better service which was a big factor in my decision in choosing CIA as my insurance agency.  Thank you very much and & I will be more than happy to recommend your agency and Ann to my Friends.”

Thomas Noonan – Mechanicsburg, PA

 

“My husband and I moved to PA just over 10 years ago.  When we purchased our home, Consumers Insurance Agency wrote my homeowners policy and shortly afterwards, we added our auto policy.  We have since added additional policies as our needs have grown.  The agents are friendly, courteous & knowledgeable.  We trust the folks at Consumers Insurance to understand and meet our needs in a professional, timely, and informative manner.  We have never been disappointed.”

Pat and Gary Hesson – Middletown, PA

 

 “I would like to take this opportunity to thank Consumers Insurance Agency, and specifically Ann Byrne, our agent, for providing outstanding service.  My parents recently moved in with us and Ann made sure that we had the correct coverage during construction and after the move.  Ann also explained and rewrote coverage for my 84 year old parents.  We know we have the best homeowners and auto coverage be we also have a good friend and agent we can trust.”

Paula Dougherty – Harrisburg, PA

 

“My experience with CIA has exceeded my very high expectations.  They are courteous, knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely interested in matching their clients with the right coverage at a very competitive price.  I was attracted by their ability to meet all insurance needs under “one roof.”  But when I found out they could do so while upgrading my coverage and STILL save me money, I knew I had found a special place.  Kudos to Eric, Ann, and the rest of the team at CIA for putting the customer first!”

Mike Chirieleison – Camp Hill, PA

 

“The process of getting my homeowner’s insurance policy was so easy!  I saved hundreds of dollars over other quotes I received.  Over the past two years I’ve been very pleased to do business with Erie.  They offer many payment options that suit my budget.  My agent, Ann, has been wonderful and is always so friendly when answering my questions.”

Jennifer Greene – Harrisburg, PA

 

“We have been customers of Consumers Insurance Agency for nearly twenty years, initially for our home and automobiles.  We have since added business coverage for liability and commercial properties.  In all of our dealings, Consumers has not just sold us insurance, they made sure we have the coverage and protection we really needed.

Ed and Tib Staub – Staub & Associates, York, PA

 

“CIA has made my life so much simpler and easier since choosing them as my insurance vendor.  The processes they have in place along with their communication style; I have a very good comfort level that I am taken care of.”

Tony Lardarello – Kasual Computing, Camp Hill, PA

 

“Consumers Insurance is tops in every aspect of insurance.  We have personal and business insurance with them and no matter when we call or what help we need, everyone we’ve dealt with has been kind and courteous.  When they say they’ll find an answer for you, you can be sure they will.  We feel like extended family when we call Consumers.  We recommend them to everyone that asks who our insurance agent is.”

Dennis and Cathy Davenport – Specialty Coatings Painting Contractors Inc., Lewisberry, PA

 

“Ann Byrne saved us money on our auto, home, and umbrella policies while at the same time increasing some of the limits on the auto policy and adding identity theft protection on our homeowners policy.  She did a great job on reviewing our coverage and making recommendations to insure we are adequately covered.  Most important, she saved us money.”

John and Mary Ascani – Mechanicsburg, PA

 

“Ann Byrne was helpful going over my policy with me.  She shed some light on some things that I needed and didn’t need on my policy.”

Joseph D. Ciccocioppo – New Bloomfield, PA

 

“Eric and his team at Consumers Insurance Agency have handled not only my personal insurance but also the insurance program for the Pennsylvania Retailers’ Association (PRA) for many years.  Eric’s expertise in the more complex areas of commercial insurance and Directors and Officers liability insurance have ensured that we not only get the protection we need, but we get it at an extremely good price.  That’s why Consumers Insurance Agency has been endorsed by the PRA as the insurance provider of choice.”

Brian A Rider, President – Pennsylvania Retailers’ Association

 

“Consumers Insurance Agency is fantastic!  It’s as simple as that.”

Nancy Read – Enola, PA

 

“I have been with Consumers Insurance Agency since 1995 and have had a wonderful experience with them.  They are always so helpful when I call for something.  I have had to bug Ann numerous times over the last 2 ½ to 3 years and she never acts as if I am being a huge pain.  I can see myself with them for the rest of my life.  I just have no reason to change what works.”

Joyce Shellenberger – Camp Hill, PA

 

“CIA was very easy to deal with.  Smooth transactions when adding or removing vehicles.  Prices are very good, and the reps are courteous and friendly.”

Gregory Ponder – New Cumberland, PA

 

“I was shopping for better rates for my insurance needs, and was referred to Consumers Insurance Agency.  The rates and coverage were great, but the service was spectacular.  Ann Byrne was patient and seamlessly helped me transfer my ten policies.  My final decision as to which company I would use came down to the service I received from Ann.”

John Linton – York, PA

 

“Finding Ann Byrne to direct our insurance needs was a blessing.  In all our years of dealing with the industry, we never experienced a more knowledgeable agent.  Professionalism to the core!”

George & Sandy Daily – New Cumberland, PA

 

“Our company provides a wide array of technology based services. From web and email hosting to website design and e-commerce, to systems sales and support, we do it all. To my knowledge, no other insurance agency really understands what we even do let alone is able to provide us with the protection we need. Eric and his team at Consumers Insurance Agency speak our language. A few years ago Eric switched us from Erie Insurance to another company because they could offer us a more complete program. In addition, he has helped us with our employee handbook and consulted with us on employee and contract issues. He even handled our LLC filing. We highly recommend Consumers Insurance Agency to any tech company.”

Jennifer Ebersole – Computer Development Systems, LLC, New Cumberland, PA

 

“I am like a lot of other people my age, you get comfortable with things the way they are, you don’t make waves or ask questions.  When I did have a question, I would call and get an answering machine.  I think after the seven or eight different questions they asked, I would be confused, my question didn’t fit so I would hang up.  Ann Byrne called me, Ann talked to me, she took her time, gave explanations for my questions.  Ann wasn’t in any hurry, explaining point after point to me.  After we were done talking she said she would call back in two mornings.  Ann called when she said she would.  This is almost unheard of nowadays, as far as I have experienced.  Ann went over everything with me asking me if I understood what she was saying.  Again, Ann took her time, wasn’t in any hurry.  Ann quoted me prices for my car insurance and homeowner’s insurance.  I couldn’t believe it; I asked her two more times.  Erie saved me almost $800.00 over AIC.  I called AIC, they never called me back.  Ann also saved me $150.00 on my homeowner’s policy with Allstate.  Erie’s policy gave me more coverage for less.  What can I say; I saved $950.00 a year!  Why did I change?  Ann took her time, explained everything to me, didn’t push me, and made things easy for me to understand.   I had Allstate’s homeowner’s policy for approximately thirty years, in that time my agent never called and talked to me about my insurance.  I will tell my friends to call Consumers Insurance Agency, and ask for Ann.”

Michael Boyanowski – Etters, PA

 

“Doug Spigelmyer has been a helpful and trusted part of our team for many years.  We are in the real estate business and do a lot of investing.  Doug has been there for us as an advisor as well as providing us with great products and great services.”

Cal Williams - Straub & Associates Real Estate

 

"Consumers Insurance Agency has provided me with very reasonably priced insurance for years.  They council me on changes which will improve my insurance coverage."

Betty Ulerick – Harrisburg, PA

 

"I have been an old timer for many years with Consumers Insurance Agency and have been pleased with the service I have received.  Diane has always taken the time with me to answer any questions and very courteous.  Doug has been kind also whenever I speak to him. "

Doris Topper – Harrisburg, PA

 

"Doug and his staff are #1 when it comes to customer service.  They were always ready and eager to help me with all my insurance needs.  I never had to wait for an appointment.  During my last insurance audit, Doug walked me through it step-by-step and explained exactly what to do.  As long as I’m in business, Consumers will be my insurance company.  Thanks for your help, like always."

Michael Rice – Rice Professional Wallcovering Installation

 

"When I called consumers to ask about a discount since our college freshman won’t be driving at school, they were very helpful.  She quoted me a new fee as well as offered another discount if my son and I came in and watched a video.  Our agent was very courteous and professional.  The savings will be very nice to have now that we have college fees!"

Jeffrey A. Prete – Mechanicsburg, PA

 
More on Page 2

240 South 18th Street, Camp Hill, PA 17011
Phone:  (717) 763-7631 © 2000 Consumers Insurance, Inc.
Website Designed and Maintained by Computer Development Systems, LLC