Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say about Consumers Insurance Agency! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.



  • Amanda Welker
    ...the transition from renter’s to homeowner’s insurance was seemless!Read Full Review

    “I began with a single auto policy and a renter’s policy. After I got married, Paul made it easy to add my husband to the auto policy. When we bought our first home, the transition from renter’s to homeowner’s insurance was seemless! ”

  • Papo Cruz
    Friendly Staff. Very Welcoming!Read Full Review

    “Friendly Staff. Very Welcoming! Ann is our Agent, and she is the BEST! My Grandmother is also with them as well, i forget her agents name? She said he’s really good too. (sorry not helpful) Forgive me!”

  • Devon Horton
    Best Insurance company around!
  • DM
    ...SAVED US OVER $7,500 in the process!!!Read Full Review

    “So far you’ve fixed a very serious flaw on our Malpractice Insurance… But here’s the best part; you gave us MUCH BETTER PROTECTION AND SAVED US OVER $7,500 in the process!!! THANK YOU so much!”

  • PA
    We have never been disappointed.Read Full Review

    “My husband and I moved to PA just over 10 years ago. When we purchased our home, Consumers Insurance Agency wrote my homeowners policy and shortly afterwards, we added our auto policy. We have since added additional policies as our needs have grown. The agents are friendly, courteous & knowledgeable. We trust the folks at Consumers Insurance to understand and meet our needs in a professional, timely, and informative manner. We have never been disappointed.”

  • EA
    ...made sure we have the coverage and protection we really needed.Read Full Review

    “We have been customers of Consumers Insurance Agency for nearly twenty years, initially for our home and automobiles. We have since added business coverage for liability and commercial properties. In all of our dealings, Consumers has not just sold us insurance, they made sure we have the coverage and protection we really needed. ”

  • DS
    ...all of our questions were answered...Read Full Review

    “We have been customers for many years. Recently we dealt with Ann on trying to insure our 18 year old son. With multiple phone calls and different scenarios we were able to come up with the cheapest way to insure him with premium insurance. Thanks to Ann all of our questions were answered and he is covered.

  • WA
    Eric and his team convincingly demonstrated their expertise...Read Full Review

    “Insuring my commercial real estate through Consumers Insurance Agency makes all the sense in the world. Eric and his team convincingly demonstrated their expertise by helping me discover what I needed, and then matched me with the program that made the most sense for my situation. Even though I’m in York and they’re in Camp Hill, I find it very easy to do business with them.”

  • JZ
    We have had nothing but positive experiences with Consumers Insurance Agency...Read Full Review

    “We have had nothing but positive experiences with Consumers Insurance Agency / Erie Insurance. The quick and efficient response we got after an accident helped us get through a frustrating time with a lot less hassle.”

  • NR
    Consumers Insurance Agency is fantastic! It’s as simple as that.
  • VK
    My new auto and renters monthly premium was $60 less per month,...Read Full Review

    “I was not looking for an insurance quote when a friend of mine suggested I might want to talk to Consumers. Although I already knew of their great reputation I had Geico and was sure I had the best rates out there. Boy was I wrong. Ann immediately contacted me and by the end of the day I had my quote. My new auto and renters monthly premium was $60 less per month, $720 less annually for the exact same coverage. I would recommend Eric and his group anytime. They provided me prompt and excellent service.”

  • WA
    Eric and his team convincingly demonstrated their expertise...Read Full Review

    “Insuring my commercial real estate through Consumers Insurance Agency makes all the sense in the world. Eric and his team convincingly demonstrated their expertise by helping me discover what I needed, and then matched me with the program that made the most sense for my situation. Even though I’m in York and they’re in Camp Hill, I find it very easy to do business with them.

  • RV
    Had the lowest contract insurance available. Quick service and flexible payment.
  • JS
    My agent was able to answer all my questions...Read Full Review

    “Selecting the correct coverage when I added my daughter to my policy was a concern. My agent was able to answer all my questions and provide me with the most cost effective coverage on the auto my daughter was driving. She even had a small fender bender and the claims process was a breeze.

  • PA
    The agents are friendly, courteous & knowledgeable.Read Full Review

    ““My husband and I moved to PA just over 10 years ago. When we purchased our home, Consumers Insurance Agency wrote my homeowners policy and shortly afterwards, we added our auto policy. We have since added additional policies as our needs have grown. The agents are friendly, courteous & knowledgeable. We trust the folks at Consumers Insurance to understand and meet our needs in a professional, timely, and informative manner. We have never been disappointed.